Free U.S. Shipping on Orders Over $79. Use Code: SM79SHIP. Each offer has a limited duration that expires at the specified time. Some promotions may require that you enter a code. By making a purchase featuring a discount or promotion, including where a code may be required, you are agreeing to these terms and exclusions. Generally, eligibility will be as reflected in the price shown on the product page. However, discounts and promotions for certain products may only appear once an item is added to the cart and the code is entered. Prices and fees, including any applicable discount(s), will be as reflected in the cart. Only the as-discounted retail price (excluding applicable shipping, taxes, and handling fees) counts toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. If a rewards program applies, the rewards may only apply to the as-discounted retail price. Discounts and promotions do not apply to gift cards. Gift card purchases do not count toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. Exclusions may apply, including: all auctions and product drops; product that is already on sale, of limited quantity, for recent championship or other special events; trading cards and certain memorabilia; select jerseys, on-field headwear, die cast and certain collectibles; and certain premium brand product. Additional terms and other exclusions may apply in our sole discretion. Items listed as FINAL SALE on the product page are final sale and cannot be returned. Free shipping promotions are valid in Continental U.S., US Territories, and AFO/FPO only, such promotions exclude heavy, large, and/or bulky items, and free shipping does not apply to the extent your cart at checkout contains any excluded item(s). Shipping method and timing may vary. Expected delivery times are based on in-stock items and the specified zip code, if applicable. Delivery estimates are not guaranteed.
  1. MLB Memorabilia
  2. New York Yankees
  3. Gary Sheffield Memorabilia
  4. over $60
  5. Signed
1 - 72 of 83
Your Search
BaseballsHelmetsJerseysPhotosTrading Cards
83 Items
BaseballsHelmetsJerseysPhotosTrading Cards
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$126.99
2025 Topps ASG Gary Sheffield #HHAGS Homegrown Heros Auto /50 Baseball Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$143.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Signed Mlb Baseball Jsa Witnessed Coa
Ships Free
$121.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Official MLB Baseball New York Yankees "509 HR" Beckett BAS Witness Stock #224700
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$79.99
Gary Sheffield Benito Santiago Marlins Signed 8x10 Photo Beckett Bp26506
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$106.99
Gary Sheffield JSA COA Autograph OAL American League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$161.99
GARY SHEFFIELD Signed ROOKIE ERA Official Baseball-BREWERS-BRAVES-YANKEES-JSA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$163.99
Gary Sheffield Braves,yankees Faded Psa/dna/coa Signed Game Used Batting Glove
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$197.99
Gary Sheffield Signed Louisville Slugger Pro Stock Blonde Baseball Bat
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Autographed Gary Sheffield Ball - ONL Dodgers Braves Padres Marlins W COA
Almost Gone!
$64.99
Signed Gary Sheffield Photo - PSA DNA Coa Rookie 8x10
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Official 1997 League Championship Series Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$94.99
Gary Sheffield Yankees Signed Autographed 8x10 MiLB Zephyers ROOKIE Photo JSA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$118.99
GARY SHEFFIELD 2004 FLEER NATIONAL PASTIME SIGNATURE SWINGS AUTO #d /26
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$99.99
Gary Sheffield (Marlins/Yankees) signed Rawlings MLB baseball-MLB Authentic
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$126.99
Gary Sheffield Marlins Signed Autograph Official OMLB Baseball BAS Beckett *83
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$126.99
Gary Sheffield Brewers Padres Yankees Signed Autograph OMLB Baseball PSA DNA *92
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$129.99
Gary Sheffield Signed New York Yankees Replica Souvenir Batting Helmet
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$79.99
Gary Sheffield #3 Tigers Signed Autographed Yankee Stadium Baseball W/ Coa
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$96.99
Chuck Carr Alex Arias Gary Sheffield Autographed Official National League Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$79.99
Gary Sheffield Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS Signed 1992 Donruss Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$105.99
Autographed Gary Sheffield Photograph - 16 x 20
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$104.99
Gary Sheffield Beckett BAS Signed 1989 Topps Future Star Rookie Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$143.99
Gary Sheffield Marlins Signed Auto 1997 Ws Baseball Beckett Auth
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$150.99
Gary Sheffield Gem Mint 10 PSA DNA Signed 1989 Fleer Rookie Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$103.99
Gary Sheffield Signed 1991 Upper Deck Baseball #266 Card Beckett Auto
Almost Gone!
$73.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Official Major League Baseball (MLB)
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$126.99
Gary Sheffield Brewers Padres Yankees Signed Autograph OMLB Baseball PSA DNA *92
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$106.99
Gary Sheffield Signed/Auto 1997 World Series Baseball Marlins PSA/DNA 190572
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$155.99
Marlins Gary Sheffield Signed Robert Manfred Oml Baseball BAS #BP33060
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$96.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed 8X10 Yankees Baseball Photo (JSA)
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$86.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed 8x10 Color Photo (framed & Matted) - Ny Yankees!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$89.99
AUTOGRAPHED GARY SHEFFIELD and DOC GOODEN 8x10 New York Yankees Photo
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$127.99
Gary Sheffield Marlins/braves/yankees Signed Autographed M.l. Baseball Beckett A
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$90.99
Gary Sheffield Signed/Auto Yankees 100th OML Baseball JSA 186706
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$90.99
1989 St. Vincent Rookies Stamp Gary Sheffield ROOKIE PSA 8 Graded Baseball Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$143.99
Gary Sheffield Signed Official MLB Baseball Marlins Yankees Auto 500 HR MLB COA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$103.99
Gary Sheffield JSA Cert Autograph National League Signed Baseball 1
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$130.99
1990 Topps #718 Gary Sheffield AUTO SIGNED Autograph Card PSA/DNA Baseball COA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$112.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Ball - OMLB Padres Marlins Brewers Dodgers Players Own Hologram Sheff
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$90.99
Gary Sheffield Signed - Autographed Inside Power Hardcover Book with PSA/DNA Authenticity - New York Yankees
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$128.99
Gary Sheffield Signed Baseball Rawlings Coleman NL (JSA NN58624)
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$103.99
Gary Sheffield JSA Cert Signed Major League OML Autograph Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$138.99
Gary Sheffield Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS Signed 1989 Donruss Rated Rookie Autograp
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$90.99
Gary Sheffield Signed/Auto Yankees 100th OML Baseball JSA 186706
Almost Gone!
$73.99
Gary Sheffield Yankees,braves,padres Jsa/stamp Of Approval Signed Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$103.99
Gary Sheffield JSA Cert Autograph National League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$104.99
Gary Sheffield Beckett Coa Autograph National League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$143.99
Gary Sheffield Gem Mint 10 PSA DNA Signed 1989 Donruss Rookie Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$101.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed 8x10 Photo (framed & Matted) - New York Yankees!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$128.99
Gary Sheffield Signed Baseball Rawlings White NL (BAS AC02974)
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$123.99
Autographed GARY SHEFFIELD Official Major League Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$107.99
GARY SHEFFIELD signed (DODGERS -YANKEES) Major League OML baseball JSA AX31860
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$144.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Official MLB Baseball - BAS
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$171.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Signed OML Black Baseball (JSA Witness COA)
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$326.99
1990 Topps Glossy Rookies Gary Sheffield #25 Rookie SGC 7.5 DA039920
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$163.99
1989 St. Vincent Rookies Stamp Gary Sheffield ROOKIE PSA 9 Graded Baseball Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$490.99
1989 St. Vincent Rookies Stamp Gary Sheffield ROOKIE PSA 10 Graded Baseball Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$272.99
Gary Sheffield 400 Hr 7/27/04 Ny Yankees Signed Auto Oml Baseball Jsa Sheff
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$224.99
Gary Sheffield 509 HRs, 9x AS Auto Louisville Slugger Black Baseball Bat - BAS
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$228.99
Gary Sheffield Signed Baseball Bat - metsjsa coa Big Stick
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$235.99
Gary Sheffield Autograph 1989 Upper Deck #13 Signed Baseball ROOKIE Card BAS 10
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$217.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat (500 Hr Club) W/ Proof!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$739.99
Gary Sheffield UNSIGNED Black Tuff Bat Game Used Baseball Bat Yankees 192242
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$217.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat (500 Hr Club) W/ Proof!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$166.99
GARY SHEFFIELD Signed Autograph Auto NL Baseball SWEET SPOT JSA COA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$163.99
Signed Gary Sheffield Picture - doc Gooden Ny ws Champs hof Jsa coa 16x20
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$923.99
Gary Sheffield Arizona Cactus League 89 Signed Rookie Signature Baseball JSA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$157.99
Gary Sheffield Gem Mint 10 Mint 9 PSA DNA Signed 1989 Topps Future Star Rookie A
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$171.99
2022 Topps Archives Signature Series Gary Sheffield 1/1 Mint Auto Sealed
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$217.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat (500 Hr Club) W/ Proof!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$244.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Uniform - Jsa coa
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$429.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Baseball - Official Major League 1997 World Series JSA
BaseballsHelmetsJerseysPhotosTrading Cards

Player Shops