HURRY! ENDS IN:
HURRY! ENDS IN:
08HRS
10MIN
40SEC
Save 20% Sitewide.
1 - 72 of 107
Your Search
107 Items
$119.99 with code
Regular: $149.99
You Save: $30.00

Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Autographed Baseball

Almost Gone!
$159.99 with code
Regular: $199.99
You Save: $40.00

Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Autographed New Era Cap

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $166.24
Regular: $174.99
You Save: $8.75

Andy Pettitte Autographed Baseball - Omlb Ws Champion

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
$49.59 with code
Regular: $61.99
You Save: $12.40

2010 Topps #56 Andy Pettitte Yankees Psa 10 B2982142-209

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $128.24
Regular: $134.99
You Save: $6.75

Andy Pettitte Autographed Photo - Cd 8x10 FRAMED

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $256.49
Regular: $269.99
You Save: $13.50

Andy Pettitte Autographed Jersey - Majestic NY PSA DNA AG51699

Almost Gone!
$119.99 with code
Regular: $149.99
You Save: $30.00

Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Autographed Black Leather Baseball

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $661.49
Regular: $734.99
You Save: $73.50

Autographed Andy Pettitte Photo - 16x20 2009 WS Framed Coin Steiner COA

Almost Gone!
$111.99 with code
Regular: $139.99
You Save: $28.00

Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Pitching Photograph

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $159.59
Regular: $167.99
You Save: $8.40

Andy Pettitte Autographed Baseball - Official Holo #LH797970

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,023.29
Regular: $1,136.99
You Save: $113.70

Andy Pettitte Autographed Jersey - COMMEMORATIVE RETIREMENT BECKETT

Almost Gone!
$43.99 with code
Regular: $54.99
You Save: $11.00

2013 Topps #506 Andy Pettitte Yankees Pop 5 Psa 10 B2957464-574

Almost Gone!
$49.59 with code
Regular: $61.99
You Save: $12.40

1996 Topps #378 Andy Pettitte Yankees Psa 10 B2982467-202

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $240.34
Regular: $252.99
You Save: $12.65

2018 Topps Brooklyn Collection Andy Pettitte Auto 17/25 - PSA 10

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
$319.99 with code
Regular: $399.99
You Save: $80.00

Roger Clemens and Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Autographed Baseball

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $345.79
Regular: $363.99
You Save: $18.20

Andy Pettitte Autographed Bat - Worth Model Core Four JSA 99

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $13,049.09
Regular: $14,498.99
You Save: $1,449.90

New York Yankees Andy Pettitte Game Used Signed Inscribed 2013 Jersey Steiner 46

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $654.29
Regular: $726.99
You Save: $72.70

Autographed Andy Pettitte Jersey - Wsc Stat Tristar

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $207.09
Regular: $217.99
You Save: $10.90

Andy Pettitte Signed Baseball - 5x Wsc Pitcher Vintage Jsa

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $10,685.69
Regular: $11,872.99
You Save: $1,187.30

Andy Pettitte Signed Inscribed Last Win Yankee Stadium 8/22/13 Mlb-steiner Holos

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $13,049.09
Regular: $14,498.99
You Save: $1,449.90

New York Yankees Andy Pettitte Game Used Signed Inscribed 2013 Gu Jersey Steiner

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $4,001.39
Regular: $4,445.99
You Save: $444.60

Rare Andy Pettitte 2000 World Series Game Used Jersey & Undershirt With COA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $327.74
Regular: $344.99
You Save: $17.25

Signed Andy Pettitte Ball - Official 2005 World Series PSA DNA Z22196

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $414.19
Regular: $435.99
You Save: $21.80

Andy Pettitte Autographed Jersey - Custom ) - Jsa Coa!

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $9,458.09
Regular: $10,508.99
You Save: $1,050.90

Andy Pettitte Signed Baseball - Inscribed 9 28 13 Final Complete Game steiner 1 1

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $259.34
Regular: $272.99
You Save: $13.65

Andy Pettitte Autographed Jersey - Custom Gray JSA B)

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
$479.99 with code
Regular: $599.99
You Save: $120.00

Framed Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Autographed Majestic Replica Jersey

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $589.49
Regular: $654.99
You Save: $65.50

Andy Pettitte Signed Jersey - PSA DNA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $139.64
Regular: $146.99
You Save: $7.35

Andy Pettitte Autographed 2017 Panini Flawless Greats Card

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $155.79
Regular: $163.99
You Save: $8.20

Autographed Andy Pettitte Photograph - BECKETT 8x10

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $134.89
Regular: $141.99
You Save: $7.10

Autographed Andy Pettitte Ball - JSA Authentic Little League

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $175.74
Regular: $184.99
You Save: $9.25

Andy Pettitte Autographed Baseball - JSA Coa Major League OML

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $262.19
Regular: $275.99
You Save: $13.80

Autographed Andy Pettitte Photo - Framed 8x10 BAS

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $204.24
Regular: $214.99
You Save: $10.75

Andy Pettitte Autographed Ball - PSA DNA Coa 1994 AllStar

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!

About Andy Pettitte Autographed Memorabilia & Collectibles

Andrew Pettitte is a widely recognized former member of the New York Yankees that was regarded as a top MLB starting pitcher. Pettitte pitched for the Yankees during the majority of his, but also spent a short time with the Houston Astros. The left-handed pitcher is known for his exceptional pickoff move to first base and cut fastball, which resulted in Pettitte being the only major league to play at least 18 seasons without a losing record.

After making his major league debut with the Yankees in 1995, Andy Pettitte instantly contributed to the franchise’s success and became a part of the “Core Four”, which also included Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, and Jorge Posada. As a member of the Yankees, Pettitte contributed to five World Series Championships and is the MLB’s all-time postseason wins leader (19). He also won the 2001 ALCS MVP Award for his contribution in the Yankees American League pennant that year. Among all NY Yankees pitchers, Andy Pettitte holds the franchise record from strikeouts and games started, as well as ranks third in wins. With a legacy at one of the MLB’s top franchises, it’s no surprise fans and collectors alike desire autographed Andy Pettitte collectibles.

Our selection of Andy Pettitte signed items includes baseballs, jerseys, photos and more. An item signed by Pettitte instantly adds value to any collection or makes the perfect gift.
No Yankees collection would be complete without items signed by all of the franchise stars of yesterday and today, so shop for autographed memorabilia featuring Babe Ruth and C.C. Sabathia as well.