Free U.S. Shipping on Orders Over $79. Use Code: SM79SHIP. Each offer has a limited duration that expires at the specified time. Some promotions may require that you enter a code. By making a purchase featuring a discount or promotion, including where a code may be required, you are agreeing to these terms and exclusions. Generally, eligibility will be as reflected in the price shown on the product page. However, discounts and promotions for certain products may only appear once an item is added to the cart and the code is entered. Prices and fees, including any applicable discount(s), will be as reflected in the cart. Only the as-discounted retail price (excluding applicable shipping, taxes, and handling fees) counts toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. If a rewards program applies, the rewards may only apply to the as-discounted retail price. Discounts and promotions do not apply to gift cards. Gift card purchases do not count toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. Exclusions may apply, including: all auctions and product drops; product that is already on sale, of limited quantity, for recent championship or other special events; trading cards and certain memorabilia; select jerseys, on-field headwear, die cast and certain collectibles; and certain premium brand product. Additional terms and other exclusions may apply in our sole discretion. Items listed as FINAL SALE on the product page are final sale and cannot be returned. Free shipping promotions are valid in Continental U.S., US Territories, and AFO/FPO only, such promotions exclude heavy, large, and/or bulky items, and free shipping does not apply to the extent your cart at checkout contains any excluded item(s). Shipping method and timing may vary. Expected delivery times are based on in-stock items and the specified zip code, if applicable. Delivery estimates are not guaranteed.
  1. MLB Memorabilia
  2. New York Yankees
  3. Gary Sheffield Memorabilia
1 - 72 of 155
Your Search
BaseballsHelmetsJerseysPhotosTrading Cards
155 Items
BaseballsHelmetsJerseysPhotosTrading Cards
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$143.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Signed Mlb Baseball Jsa Witnessed Coa
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$126.99
2025 Topps ASG Gary Sheffield #HHAGS Homegrown Heros Auto /50 Baseball Card
Almost Gone!
$24.99
1990 Score Gary Sheffield BGS 9 Game-used Jersey Card
Almost Gone!
$48.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Donruss #31 PSA 8
Almost Gone!
$25.99
Gary Sheffield Card 2008 Topps Moments & Milestones #52
Almost Gone!
$26.99
Gary Sheffield player worn jersey patch baseball card (New York Yankees) 2006 Upper Deck Materials #UDGS
Almost Gone!
$28.99
Gary Sheffield 2003 Topps Bomb Squad Game-Used Bat Card
Almost Gone!
$30.99
1989 Topps #343 Gary Sheffield ROOKIE RC PSA 8 Graded Baseball Card Future Star
Almost Gone!
$27.99
Gary Sheffield 2004 Topps Bazooka Blasts #BB-GS Game-Used Bat
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$43.99
1989 Topps #343 Gary Sheffield ROOKIE RC PSA 9 Graded Baseball Card MINT Star
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9
Almost Gone!
$48.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Donruss #31 PSA 9
Almost Gone!
$32.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed 8x10 Baseball Photo
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$79.99
Gary Sheffield Benito Santiago Marlins Signed 8x10 Photo Beckett Bp26506
Almost Gone!
$23.99
Autographed JASON GRILLI Detroit Tigers 2007 Topps Card
Almost Gone!
$24.99
2001 UD Sweet Spot GARY SHEFFIELD Game Used Bat Card
Almost Gone!
$21.99
Gary Sheffield 1990 Donruss Game Used Jersey #501 BGS 8.5 (Read Description)
Almost Gone!
$24.99
Gary Sheffield 2004 Topps Bazooka #BBGS Bat Card
Almost Gone!
$28.99
Gary Sheffield 2002 Upper Deck Game-Worn Jersey Card
Almost Gone!
$28.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Topps #343 BCCG 10
Almost Gone!
$28.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Bowman #142 PSA 9
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9.5 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (8.5 9 9 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS BCCG 10
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Fleer Glossy #196
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$40.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Picture - Early Jsa Cert Sticker 8x10 Authentic
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$32.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed 8x10 Baseball Photo
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 PSA 9
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card 1989 Upper Deck #13 BGS 9 (9.5 9 8.5 9)
Almost Gone!
$32.99
Gary Sheffield Fall Memories Topps Pristine Game Used Bat Card #FMGS /1600
Almost Gone!
$48.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed 8x10 Baseball Photo
Almost Gone!
$45.99
Gary Sheffield Signed 1997 Topps Finest Marlins Card #176 PSA/DNA COA Autograph
Almost Gone!
$45.99
Gary Sheffield Signed 1993 Pinnacle Home Run Club Marlins Card #6 PSA/DNA COA
Almost Gone!
$48.99
Gary Sheffield 2001 Upper Deck Autographed Patch Card #JGS
Almost Gone!
$48.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed 2007 Topps Card
Ships Free
$121.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Official MLB Baseball New York Yankees "509 HR" Beckett BAS Witness Stock #224700
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$106.99
Gary Sheffield JSA COA Autograph OAL American League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$161.99
GARY SHEFFIELD Signed ROOKIE ERA Official Baseball-BREWERS-BRAVES-YANKEES-JSA
Almost Gone!
$53.99
AUTOGRAPHED GARY SHEFFIELD 8x10 New York Yankees Photo
Almost Gone!
$54.99
Gary Sheffield Baseball Player Signed 3x5 Index Card JSA Authenticated
Almost Gone!
$59.99
Autographed Sheffield Picture - Psa dna 8x10 Authentic
Almost Gone!
$53.99
AUTOGRAPHED GARY SHEFFIELD 8x10 New York Yankees Photo
Almost Gone!
$53.99
AUTOGRAPHED GARY SHEFFIELD 8x10 New York Yankees Photo
Almost Gone!
$53.99
AUTOGRAPHED GARY SHEFFIELD 8x10 New York Yankees Photo
Almost Gone!
$53.99
AUTOGRAPHED GARY SHEFFIELD 8x10 New York Yankees Photo
Almost Gone!
$53.99
Autographed GARY SHEFFIELD New York Yankees, Detroit Tigers 2007 Topps Card
Almost Gone!
$46.99
Gary Sheffield Card 2004 Topps Black #370
Almost Gone!
$48.99
Gary Sheffield 2004 Fleer Game Used Patch Card /50
Almost Gone!
$45.99
Gary Sheffield Signed Cut Photo Baseball Marlins Auto Best Wishes Inscr PSA/DNA
Almost Gone!
$59.99
Gary Sheffield Signed 2004 Playoff Absolute Card #144 Yankees PSA/DNA 195147
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Autographed Gary Sheffield Ball - ONL Dodgers Braves Padres Marlins W COA
Almost Gone!
$64.99
Signed Gary Sheffield Photo - PSA DNA Coa Rookie 8x10
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Gary Sheffield Autographed Official 1997 League Championship Series Baseball
Almost Gone!
$51.99
Gary Sheffield Card 2005 Topps Black #40
Almost Gone!
$49.99
Gary Sheffield Signed Photo - Original 1 1 8x10 Jsa Cert Sticker Authentic Autogra
Almost Gone!
$51.99
Autographed Gary Sheffield Photograph - 8x10
BaseballsHelmetsJerseysPhotosTrading Cards