Ends Wednesday at 11:59 PM ET
Up To 65% Off Sitewide. Shop Now.
1 - 72 of 79
Baseballs
79 Items
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $333.44
Regular: $350.99
You Save: $17.55

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - Gold Glove JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $2,312.09
Regular: $2,568.99
You Save: $256.90

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - 1986 WSC NY Team 35x Gooden + PSA DNA 9 LOA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $251.74
Regular: $264.99
You Save: $13.25

1987 New York Mets Team Signed Autographed Baseball With Gary Carter

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $153.89
Regular: $161.99
You Save: $8.10

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball (JSA)

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $421.79
Regular: $443.99
You Save: $22.20

1980's New York Mets Team Signed Baseball Gary Carter Gooden Strawberry

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,643.39
Regular: $1,825.99
You Save: $182.60

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - 1986 Official World Series 35 PSA DNA LOA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,601.99
Regular: $1,779.99
You Save: $178.00

Autographed Gary Carter Ball - Beautiful Heavily Inscribed Career STAT JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $345.79
Regular: $363.99
You Save: $18.20

Gary Carter Signed Baseball - Offical Major League Hof Coa

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $360.04
Regular: $378.99
You Save: $18.95

Autographed Gary Carter Baseball - 1986 WS Champs PSA DNA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $131.09
Regular: $137.99
You Save: $6.90

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - Official NL Expos Beckett BAS #F22355

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $319.19
Regular: $335.99
You Save: $16.80

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - HOF 2003 PSA COA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $276.44
Regular: $290.99
You Save: $14.55

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - Rare Oml Ny Legend Coa

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $242.24
Regular: $254.99
You Save: $12.75

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - Expos N l Jsa Q17988

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $353.39
Regular: $371.99
You Save: $18.60

Gary Carter Signed Ball - Official Ins Mvp As 81 84 RJ com Coa

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $439.84
Regular: $462.99
You Save: $23.15

Signed Gary Carter Baseball - 1983 All Star Game PSA DNA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $302.09
Regular: $317.99
You Save: $15.90

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - Stars 8 Wilson Ojeda + Jsa Loa

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $139.64
Regular: $146.99
You Save: $7.35

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - JSA Coa Major League OML Authentic

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $220.39
Regular: $231.99
You Save: $11.60

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - Rawlings Official Major League COA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $337.24
Regular: $354.99
You Save: $17.75

1989 New York Mets Team Signed NL Baseball Gary Carter PSA DNA COA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $497.69
Regular: $552.99
You Save: $55.30

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - Official 1986 WS Vintage CBM COA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $270.74
Regular: $284.99
You Save: $14.25

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - w/ "HOF '03

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $132.04
Regular: $138.99
You Save: $6.95

Autographed Gary Carter Baseball - Official National League

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $176.69
Regular: $185.99
You Save: $9.30

Gary Carter Signed Baseball - Official National League JSA)

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $147.24
Regular: $154.99
You Save: $7.75

Gary Carter Signed Ball - JSA Coa National League ONL

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $145.34
Regular: $152.99
You Save: $7.65

Signed Gary Carter Ball - JSA National League ONL

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $131.09
Regular: $137.99
You Save: $6.90

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - Official NL Expos Beckett BAS #F22361

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $172.89
Regular: $181.99
You Save: $9.10

Autographed Gary Carter Ball - PSA DNA Coa Feeney National League

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $251.74
Regular: $264.99
You Save: $13.25

Signed Gary Carter Ball - #8 Official American League JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $189.04
Regular: $198.99
You Save: $9.95

Signed Gary Carter Baseball - JSA Coa Feeney National League

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $139.64
Regular: $146.99
You Save: $7.35

Gary Carter Autographed Ball - JSA Cert National League ONL Authentic

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $278.34
Regular: $292.99
You Save: $14.65

Autographed Gary Carter Ball - d 2012 Expos JSA COA C

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $581.39
Regular: $645.99
You Save: $64.60

Autographed Gary Carter Ball - #8 PSA DNA HOF

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,807.19
Regular: $2,007.99
You Save: $200.80

1986 Mets World Series Team signed NL Baseball 30 auto Gary Carter PSA/DNA LOA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $800.09
Regular: $888.99
You Save: $88.90

1975 All Star Game Team Signed Baseball Tom Seaver Gary Carter JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $224.19
Regular: $235.99
You Save: $11.80

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - 1988 Sporting News Game Box HOF JSA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $147.24
Regular: $154.99
You Save: $7.75

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - JSA Coa National League ONL

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $146.29
Regular: $153.99
You Save: $7.70

Signed Gary Carter Baseball - Hof Official Ny Expos

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $131.09
Regular: $137.99
You Save: $6.90

Gary Carter Signed Ball - Official NL Expos Beckett BAS #F22356

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $337.24
Regular: $354.99
You Save: $17.75

Gary Carter Autographed Baseball - Official 1983 All Star Game JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,916.09
Regular: $2,128.99
You Save: $212.90

Gary Carter & Mike Piazza Signed 1999 NLCS First Pitch Game Used Baseball PSA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $258.39
Regular: $271.99
You Save: $13.60

Signed Gary Carter Ball - Official w PSA COA

Almost Gone!

Collectible Gary Carter New York Mets Baseballs

SportsMemorabilia.com carries an unbeatable selection of signed Mets Gary Carter baseballs to add to your official MLB collection. Browse from our assortment of authentic Gary Carter New York Mets baseballs signed by your favorite top players. An autographed Gary Carter Mets baseball is the perfect addition to any major fan's collection and also make amazing gifts. Shop with us today at SportsMemorabilia.com to find all the best, officially licensed New York Mets Gary Carter collectibles and memorabilia.