Free U.S. Shipping on Orders Over $79. Use Code: SM79SHIP. Each offer has a limited duration that expires at the specified time. Some promotions may require that you enter a code. By making a purchase featuring a discount or promotion, including where a code may be required, you are agreeing to these terms and exclusions. Generally, eligibility will be as reflected in the price shown on the product page. However, discounts and promotions for certain products may only appear once an item is added to the cart and the code is entered. Prices and fees, including any applicable discount(s), will be as reflected in the cart. Only the as-discounted retail price (excluding applicable shipping, taxes, and handling fees) counts toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. If a rewards program applies, the rewards may only apply to the as-discounted retail price. Discounts and promotions do not apply to gift cards. Gift card purchases do not count toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. Exclusions may apply, including: all auctions and product drops; product that is already on sale, of limited quantity, for recent championship or other special events; trading cards and certain memorabilia; select jerseys, on-field headwear, die cast and certain collectibles; and certain premium brand product. Additional terms and other exclusions may apply in our sole discretion. Items listed as FINAL SALE on the product page are final sale and cannot be returned. Free shipping promotions are valid in Continental U.S., US Territories, and AFO/FPO only, such promotions exclude heavy, large, and/or bulky items, and free shipping does not apply to the extent your cart at checkout contains any excluded item(s). Shipping method and timing may vary. Expected delivery times are based on in-stock items and the specified zip code, if applicable. Delivery estimates are not guaranteed.
  1. MLB Memorabilia
  2. Allie Reynolds Memorabilia
1 - 72 of 104
Your Search
Cincinnati RedsNew York MetsNew York Yankees
104 Items
Cincinnati RedsNew York MetsNew York Yankees
Almost Gone!
$32.99
1953 Topps #141 Allie Reynolds New York Yankees Baseball Card Vg/Ex lgh w/c tlc
Almost Gone!
$23.99
Allie Reynolds (d.1994) New York Yankees Autographed Signed 3x5 Index Card
Almost Gone!
$27.99
Graded GOOD
Almost Gone!
$27.99
Graded GOOD
Almost Gone!
$27.99
Graded GOOD
Almost Gone!
$38.99
Graded G/VG
Almost Gone!
$38.99
Graded G/VG
Almost Gone!
$34.99
Graded G/VG
Almost Gone!
$34.99
New York Yankees Allie Reynolds (d.89) Signed Auto Vintage 3x5 Index Card CM
Almost Gone!
$35.99
Allie Reynolds New York Yankees Signed 3x5 Index Card JSA Authenticated
Almost Gone!
$31.99
Graded VG
Almost Gone!
$32.99
Bobby Shantz Autographed Topps Archive Card
Almost Gone!
$31.99
Graded VG
Almost Gone!
$31.99
Graded G/VG
Almost Gone!
$34.99
Graded G/VG
Almost Gone!
$32.99
Graded GOOD
Almost Gone!
$38.99
Graded VG
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$562.99
Allie Reynolds PSA DNA Signed 1948 Bowman Rookie Autograph
Almost Gone!
$48.99
Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Signed 1988 Pacific Legends Autograph
Almost Gone!
$46.99
Yankees Allie Reynolds (d.94) Signed Endorsed Autograph Check from Promoter 822
Almost Gone!
$45.99
Graded G/VG
Almost Gone!
$46.99
Graded EXMT+
Almost Gone!
$52.99
Allie Reynolds Jsa Coa Autograph 3x5 Index Card Hand Signed Authentic
Almost Gone!
$52.99
Graded VGEX
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$727.99
1952 Topps #67 Allie Reynolds Black Back Psa 4 Vg-ex 06572469
Almost Gone!
$53.99
Allie Reynolds JSA Coa Autograph 1988 Pacific Signed
Almost Gone!
$53.99
Allie Reynolds New York Yankees Autographed/Signed Check 122101
Almost Gone!
$53.99
Allie Reynolds New York Yankees Autographed/Signed Check 122103
Almost Gone!
$58.99
Allie Reynolds NY Yankees (d.94) 1982 TCMA Baseballs Greatest Card Autograph JSA
Almost Gone!
$54.99
Allie Reynolds Yankees Signed Postcard with B&E Hologram
Almost Gone!
$58.99
Allie Reynolds SGC Signed 1979 TCMA History Series Autograph
Almost Gone!
$56.99
Allie Reynolds PSA DNA Signed 1988 Pacific Legends Autograph
Almost Gone!
$56.99
Allie Reynolds JSA Coa Signed Vintage 2x4 1951 Original New York Yankees Photo
Almost Gone!
$56.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed 3x5 Index Card (JSA)
Almost Gone!
$64.99
Allie Reynolds JSA COA Signed 8x10 Photo Autograph Yankees
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Allie Reynolds Signed Photograph - Deceased 1994 B w 8x10 W Coa
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Allie Reynolds autographed Baseball Card (New York Yankees) 1982 TCMA Greatest #13
Almost Gone!
$59.99
Allie Reynolds JSA Cert Signed 8x10 Photo Vintage Autograph New York Yankees
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Signed Allie Reynolds Photograph - Deceased 1994 8x10 W
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Allie Reynolds Signed Psa/dna 1949 Gpc Gov`t Postcard Autograph Authentic
Almost Gone!
$71.99
AUTOGRAPHED ALLIE REYNOLDS 8X10 Cleveland Indians Photo
Almost Gone!
$59.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed 1961 Fleer Card #16 New York Yankees PSA/DNA #83312527
Almost Gone!
$63.99
Allie Reynolds autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1988 Pacific Legends #41
Almost Gone!
$64.99
Allie Reynolds PSA DNA Signed 1988 Pacific Legends Autograph
Almost Gone!
$64.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed Yankees 8x10 Photo
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$78.99
Autographed Allie Reynolds Picture - color 8x10 2 no hitters JSA COA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$146.99
Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Signed 1953 Bowman Color Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$112.99
Allie Reynolds PSA DNA Signed 1955 Bowman Autographed
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$88.99
Allie Reynolds Signed Auto First Day Cover FDC - PSA/DNA
Almost Gone!
$65.99
Allie Reynolds PSA DNA Signed 8x10 Photo Yankees Autographed
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$101.99
Allie Reynolds Yankees Autographed Signed 8x10 Glossy Photo Print JSA Authentic
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$110.99
Allie Reynolds (d. 1994) Signed / Autographed Index Card Psa/dna Slabbed Yankees
Almost Gone!
$74.99
Graded PSA 3
Almost Gone!
$73.99
Graded EX+
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$117.99
Yankees Allie Reynolds (d.94) Signed Auto Original Dormand Post Card JSA COA A17
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$133.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed / Signed The Great American Sports Debates Contract
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$88.99
Allie Reynolds Signed Psa/dna 1948 Postmarked Gpc Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$106.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed 1955 Bowman Card #201 New York Yankees Beckett BAS #11077303
Almost Gone!
$66.99
Signed Allie Reynolds Photo - Jsa 8x10
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$79.99
1988 C.C.C. 1949 Bowman #114 Allie Reynolds AUTO SIGNED Autograph Card PSA/DNA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$130.99
Allie Reynolds NY Yankees Signed 8x10 Baseball Photo with JSA COA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$123.99
Allie Reynolds Signed 1983 TCMA #35 Card 50 Years Yankees Autograph HOF PSA/DNA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$79.99
Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Signed 1954 Bowman Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$106.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed 3x5 Index Card New York Yankees PSA/DNA 178802
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$129.99
1952-55 Dormand #109 Postcard Allie Reynolds Autographed B&E Hologram
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$81.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed 1988 Pacific Card #41 (PSA)
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$110.99
Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Signed 1955 Bowman Autograph
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$97.99
Allie Reynolds Autographed Baseball - 3x5 Vintage Postcard
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$93.99
Graded EXMT+
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$122.99
ALLIE REYNOLDS Signed Pacific Baseball Card-NEW YORK YANKEES-PSA
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$101.99
1982 TCMA Baseball Card Allie Reynolds New York Yankees Autographed NRMT
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$90.99
1952 Topps #67 Allie Reynolds PSA 1.5 Graded Baseball Card New York Yankees BB
Cincinnati RedsNew York MetsNew York Yankees