Ends Saturday at 11:59 PM ET
Up To 65% Off Sitewide. Shop Now.
Indianapolis Colts
Shop Signed Jerseys
Shop Signed Helmets
1 - 72 of 1628
Your Search
1628 Items
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $285.94
Regular: $300.99
You Save: $15.05

Adam Vinatieri Signed Ball - Super Grip Beckett BAS

Reduced: $143.99
Regular: $179.99
You Save: $36.00

Indianapolis Colts Black Frame Jersey Display Case

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $599.39
Regular: $665.99
You Save: $66.60

Autographed Peyton Manning Football

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $137.74
Regular: $144.99
You Save: $7.25

Signed Darius Leonard Jersey - White JSA COA Great

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $259.34
Regular: $272.99
You Save: $13.65

Signed Reggie Wayne Jersey - Blue Beckett COA

Reduced: $136.79
Regular: $143.99
You Save: $7.20

Peyton Manning 1998 Colts Rookie Game Worn Jersey Mystery Swatch Box!

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $145.34
Regular: $152.99
You Save: $7.65

Darius Leonard Signed Jersey - Blue Beckett BAS Stock #156853

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,601.99
Regular: $1,779.99
You Save: $178.00

1997 Indianapolis Colts Team Signed Authentic Game Issued Helmet With JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $4,871.69
Regular: $5,412.99
You Save: $541.30

Colts Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman's Best #112 RC #178/400 Card Gem 10 PSA Slab

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $124.44
Regular: $130.99
You Save: $6.55

Peyton Manning 1998 Pacific Aurora Gold #22 Rookie Card PGI 10

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $95.99
Regular: $119.99
You Save: $24.00

Darius Leonard Indianapolis Colts Autographed White Panel Football

Reduced: $47.99
Regular: $59.99
You Save: $12.00

Indianapolis Colts Black Base Football Display Case

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,250.09
Regular: $1,388.99
You Save: $138.90

Peyton Manning Signed Helmet - F S Eclipse Authentic Fanatics Auth

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,598.39
Regular: $1,775.99
You Save: $177.60

Peyton Manning Autographed Helmet - F S Camo Speed Authentic Fanatics Auth

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $693.89
Regular: $770.99
You Save: $77.10

Autographed Peyton Manning Mini Helmet - Camo Speed Fanatics Auth

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $555.29
Regular: $616.99
You Save: $61.70

Peyton Manning Autographed Mini Helmet - Eclipse Fanatics Auth

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $527.39
Regular: $585.99
You Save: $58.60

Signed Peyton Manning Mini Helmet - AMP Speed Fanatics Auth

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $168.14
Regular: $176.99
You Save: $8.85

Autographed Marlon Mack Jersey - Beckett

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $818.09
Regular: $908.99
You Save: $90.90

Peyton Manning Autographed Nike Vapor Speed Football Cleats - Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $818.09
Regular: $908.99
You Save: $90.90

Peyton Manning Autographed Nike Carbon 2.0 Football Cleats - Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $981.89
Regular: $1,090.99
You Save: $109.10

Peyton Manning Autographed Jersey - Nike Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $109.24
Regular: $114.99
You Save: $5.75

Autographed T.Y. Hilton Photo - TY 16x20 JSA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $440.79
Regular: $463.99
You Save: $23.20

2013 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Autograph 4,000 Yard Club Auto #6/25

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $164.34
Regular: $172.99
You Save: $8.65

Signed Darius Leonard Mini Helmet - South Carolina State Bulldogs Jsa

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $818.09
Regular: $908.99
You Save: $90.90

Quenton Nelson Autographed Jersey - FRAMED 33x42 White JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $589.49
Regular: $654.99
You Save: $65.50

Peyton Manning Autographed Mini Helmet - Authentic Eclipse Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $818.09
Regular: $908.99
You Save: $90.90

Peyton Manning Autographed Nike Alpha Football Cleats - Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $818.09
Regular: $908.99
You Save: $90.90

Peyton Manning Autographed Nike Blue Football Cleats - Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $818.09
Regular: $908.99
You Save: $90.90

Peyton Manning Autographed Nike Alpha Pro Football Cleats - Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,341.89
Regular: $1,490.99
You Save: $149.10

Peyton Manning Signed Helmet - F s Speed Authentic Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $1,744.19
Regular: $1,937.99
You Save: $193.80

Peyton Manning Signed Helmet - F s Authentic Speedflex Fanatics

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Reduced: $262.19
Regular: $275.99
You Save: $13.80

Marshall Faulk Signed Mini Helmet - Eclipse Speed BAS Witnessed

Reduced: $71.99
Regular: $89.99
You Save: $18.00

Indianapolis Colts Black Framed Wall-Mountable Football Display Case

Reduced: $103.99
Regular: $129.99
You Save: $26.00

Indianapolis Colts Black Framed Wall-Mounted Helmet Display

Almost Gone!
Reduced: $980.09
Regular: $1,088.99
You Save: $108.90

Peyton Manning Autographed Jersey - Nike Limited Fanatics COA

About Indianapolis Colts Autographed Memorabilia & Collectibles

Historical Milestones

The Colts franchise has their roots dating back to 1953 when they were known as the Baltimore Colts. While playing in Baltimore they won three NFL Championships and a Super Bowl title. The franchise relocated to Indianapolis in 1984 and are members of the AFC South Division, currently calling Lucas Oil Stadium their home. After moving to Indianapolis they won another Super Bowl title and have appeared in another.

During the late 1950s, Johnny Unitas took on the role of the Colts’ starting quarterback. Unitas helped revolutionize the game in a time when the league was not as pass-oriented as it is today. This Hall of Famer led the franchise to NFL titles in 1958, 1959, and 1968, as well as a title at Super Bowl V. The Colts, were a part of maybe the most important game in NFL history at Super Bowl III, losing to the New York Jets 16-7. This was the first Super Bowl victory for an AFL team and played an important role in the NFL-AFL merger that happened in 1970. Throughout the 1970s the Colts won multiple AFC East Division titles, making numerous playoff appearances led by Pro Bowlers Bert Jones and Lydell Mitchell. In 1984 the franchise moved to Indianapolis and made a few playoff appearances during the 1980s and 1990s with their best season coming in 1995 that saw quarterback Jim Harbaugh leading them to the AFC Championship Game. The 1997 NFL season would be a difficult one for the team, with only 3 victories that year. It would end up being to their benefit though because it allowed them to draft Peyton Manning with the first overall pick of the 1998 NFL Draft. Manning led the Colts to two Super Bowl appearances, winning and being named the MVP of Super Bowl XLI. After a 2-14 2011 season, they once again had the first pick of the NFL Draft. The Colts would again select another quarterback, this time Andrew Luck who is now one of the league’s top players. Prior to the 2018 NFL season, Frank Reich was named the head coach of the team after he helped lead the Philadelphia Eagles to a Super Bowl title as their offensive coordinator the previous season.

The Indianapolis Colts are an iconic NFL franchise. Their horseshoe helmet is one of the most well-known logos in all of sports and you will never regret purchasing autographed memorabilia for this franchise. Signed sports collectibles for Super Bowl Champions such as Dwight Freeney, Robert Mathis, Marvin Harrison, and Dallas Clark will look wonderful displayed in any man cave or sports room.

Collecting Indianapolis Colts Memorabilia

Peyton Manning Autographed Photos

Peyton Manning is regarded among the greatest players in NFL history. This five-time MVP Award winner passed for 71,940 yards and 539 touchdowns during his incredible career. A Manning signed a photo of him dropping back to pass and leading the Colts to victory on the field will soon become one of the most prized possessions in your sports memorabilia collection. Our photos of this fourteen-time Pro Bowler are valuable investments that will soon surge in worth. T.Y. Hilton Autographed Jerseys

Do not miss your chance to purchase an autographed T.Y. Hilton jersey. Our Hilton signed Indianapolis Colts blue or white No. 13 jerseys are always guaranteed to be authentic, so have no worries or concerns when shopping with us. Hilton was named to the 2012 All-Rookie Team and has been selected to multiple Pro Bowl Teams since being drafted in 2012. In 2016 he led the NFL in receiving yards with 1,448 yards. Tony Dungy Autographed Footballs

A signed Tony Dungy football will be a perfect addition to any sports memorabilia collection. One of our Dungy autographed Super Bowl XLI footballs is rare and unique sports collectibles that will be hard to find at any other retailers. In 2016 he was elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame and was selected to the NFL All-2000s Second-Team. After leading the Colts to a 29-17 victory over the Chicago Bear he made history by becoming the first African-American head coach to win a Super Bowl. Andrew Luck Autographed Helmets

Purchase your very own autographed Andrew Luck helmet today. A Luck signed Indianapolis Colts authentic Pro-Line Speed helmet is an excellent sports gift for any of your friends or family members who are diehard Colts fans. This quarterback has emerged as one of the best players in the league, being named to numerous Pro Bowl Teams along the way. It will be exciting to see what this future legend accomplishes throughout the rest of his NFL career. Reggie Wayne Autographed Mini Helmets

Super Bowl XLI Champion Reggie Wayne was selected to six Pro Bowl Teams over the course of his career. He was named to the First-Team All-Pro once and the Second-Team All-Pro twice and even led the NFL in receiving yards in 2007. Our signed Reggie Wayne mini helmets are rare and unique sports collectibles that are always guaranteed to be 100% authentic. The Wayne autographed Indianapolis Colts and Super XLI mini helmets that we sell are conveniently sized so they can be easily displayed in any home, office, sports room, or man cave.