Jim O'Toole (full name: James Jerome O'Toole; no nicknames) played pitcher from 1958 until 1967 for the Cincinnati Redlegs and Chicago White Sox. He played for the Redlegs from 1958 - 1966 and White Sox in 1967. Over 10 seasons, he started 238 games, won 98 games, struck out 1039 batters, and had a 3.57 ERA. Born on January 10, 1937 in Chicago, IL, O'Toole stands 6' 0" and weighs 190 lb. He attended Leo (Chicago, IL) high school. His debut was on September 26, 1958 and he played his final game on July 22, 1967. Over his career, O'Toole made $90,000. Common misspellings of his name include James james Jerome Jim jimmie jimmy O'Toole otoole.